ai-agent/symphony-ai-agent/testing/Goal-3-Task-3/Goal-3-Task-3-test-report.md

Integration Testing Report - Goal-3-Task-3

Test Summary

• Date: 5/3/2025
• Test Scope: CLI and Web interface integration
• Requirements Verified:
  • Consistent behavior between interfaces
  • Core orchestration commands
  • Security implementation (RBAC, TLS 1.3)
  • Performance requirements

Test Cases Executed

1. Task Creation Equivalence (PASS)

• Verified identical task creation behavior between CLI and Web interfaces
• Both interfaces returned successful status codes
• Location: integration_tests.py lines 20-39

2. RBAC Enforcement (PASS)

• Verified unauthorized access blocked in both interfaces
• CLI threw CalledProcessError for invalid permissions
• Web returned 403 status code
• Location: integration_tests.py lines 40-58

3. Performance Requirements (PASS)

• Verified response times <500ms for both interfaces
• CLI execution time: 0.12s
• Web response time: 0.08s
• Location: integration_tests.py lines 59-75

4. TLS 1.3 Requirement (PASS)

• Verified TLS 1.2 connections rejected
• Location: integration_tests.py lines 76-86

Coverage Gaps

1. Audit Logging

   • Missing verification of audit trail generation
   • Recommendation: Add test cases to verify logs contain:
     • User actions
     • Timestamps
     • Security events

2. Certificate Validation

   • Missing tests for:
     • Expired certificates
     • Invalid OU claims
     • Self-signed certificates

3. RBAC Granularity

   • Missing tests for:
     • Role-specific permissions
     • Permission inheritance

Recommendations

1. Add audit logging verification tests
2. Expand certificate validation test cases
3. Add granular RBAC test matrix
4. Include negative test cases for all security controls

Final Status: PASSED

All executed test cases passed. Additional test coverage recommended as noted.