ai-agent/symphony-ai-agent/testing/Goal-3-Task-3/Goal-3-Task-3-test-plan.md

Goal-3-Task-3 Test Plan

Test Objectives

1. Verify consistent behavior between CLI and Web interfaces
2. Validate security implementation (RBAC, TLS 1.3, audit logging)
3. Ensure response times <500ms for all core operations

Test Environment

• CLI: Python 3.10+ with Click
• Web: Flask with TLS 1.3
• Test certificates for RBAC validation

Test Cases

Functional Equivalence Tests

1. Task Creation

   • CLI: symphony add-task "Test task"
   • Web: POST /tasks with JSON payload
   • Verify identical task storage and response

2. Next Task Retrieval

   • CLI: symphony next-task
   • Web: GET /tasks/next
   • Verify same task returned in both interfaces

3. Task Processing

   • CLI: symphony process-task [ID]
   • Web: POST /tasks/[ID]/process
   • Verify identical state changes

4. Permission Validation

   • CLI: symphony validate-permissions [user] [permission]
   • Web: GET /permissions/validate?user=[user]&permission=[permission]
   • Verify identical RBAC results

Security Tests

1. TLS 1.3 Verification

   • Confirm only TLS 1.3 connections accepted
   • Test with older protocols (should reject)

2. RBAC Enforcement

   • Test all endpoints with:
     • Valid credentials + permissions
     • Valid credentials + invalid permissions
     • Invalid credentials

3. Audit Logging

   • Verify all operations logged with:
     • Timestamp
     • User
     • Operation
     • Status

4. Rate Limiting

   • Verify rate limits enforced on /tasks endpoint

Performance Tests

1. Response Time

   • Measure response times for all endpoints
   • Verify <500ms under load

2. Concurrency

   • Test parallel requests
   • Verify no RBAC or state corruption

Test Data

• Test users with varying permissions
• Sample task payloads
• Performance test scripts

Pass/Fail Criteria

• All functional tests must pass
• No security test failures
• 95% of requests under 500ms